| Author |
Message |
Crash Test Dummy Warnings : 3 Ministerial

Joined: 25 Sep 2005 Posts: 4911 Location: London(ish)
|
|
| Quote: |
| Even if turkey fulfils all the necessary political, economic and legal criteria for membership it should not be allowed to join the EU until the EU has undergone radical institutional change |
I know its not really about Cyprus more the EU instituions but its close enough
Discuss. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Khan
Deputy

Joined: 13 Nov 2005 Posts: 1092 Location: London
|
|
| Translation: Turkey should not be allowed to join until the EU is ready to accept Muslims. |
|
| Back to top |
|
depurple Warnings : 1 Ministerial

Joined: 06 Dec 2005 Posts: 2876 Location: Australia
|
|
OR Unless Turkey becomes Europeanised:
That is the Real Question:Can it?
Will the Military and the Islamic movement of Turkey let it?
Lets see:
Don't worry about the EU when they know 110% that Turkey thinks like a European even I will ask my friend sin the EU to make sure the Turkey gets in: Say your European and acting European is like chalk and cheese my good friend:
Its a long way to the EU unless Turkey learns to Rock & Roll: AC/DC |
|
| Back to top |
|
Khan
Deputy

Joined: 13 Nov 2005 Posts: 1092 Location: London
|
|
| I really despise terms like "think like a European". What is that meant to mean? That somehow the way Turks think now is inferior? Turkey has hundreds of years of history and culture which are in complete opposition to Europe, this is what makes it special in the EU. The EU is meant to accept new cultures, not reshape them. |
|
| Back to top |
|
depurple Warnings : 1 Ministerial

Joined: 06 Dec 2005 Posts: 2876 Location: Australia
|
|
Well Khan you better think again my friend: That thinking is NOT European and IF you think that the EU will accept Turkey thinking like you: FORGET IT!
The EU will not only reshape Turkey BUT reshape everyone including Cyprus: Freedom of Speak, Language, religion, sex so you think Turkey will be accept because it what 1000s of years old: Are you kidding:
BUT fingers crossed maybe the EU will allow Turkey to join the EU without doing one single thing:
But I wouldn't count on it:
Please don't flog the dead horse: A Christian Club just follow the EU rules and change your attitude and thinking and then Maybe ONLY Maybe Turkey might get in:
If we are all still alive to see it: |
|
| Back to top |
|
Khan
Deputy

Joined: 13 Nov 2005 Posts: 1092 Location: London
|
|
| No depurple, where in the EU criteria for Turkey to join does it say anything about "change your attitude and thinking"? This is a huge generalisation that suggests the way Turks act and think is inferior. All Turkey must do is fulfil the criteria laid out for it, once this is done, there is no excuse to reject Turkey from the EU. |
|
| Back to top |
|
depurple Warnings : 1 Ministerial

Joined: 06 Dec 2005 Posts: 2876 Location: Australia
|
|
But can it fill the criteria and don't think that by avoid some of the criteria that it has fulfilled:
I am the first person who wants Turkey in the EU WHY?
Because then I can go back to my land in Lapta and Turkey can not do a thing about it:
Also you can walk down the streets of Turkey talking Greek, Kurdish Armenian and Turkey will allow this:
You see Khan the EU criteria is not as simple as you and many other Turkish loving people think it is: In any other part of the EU religion. language and the military is in the background BUT where is it in Turkey me know:
I don't know how blind and naive people are with Turkeys EU coarse:
Fulfill the criteria and Turkey is IN?
Do you and other Turks have any idea what the criteria are?
Or do you just pick out the one you think Turkey wants and say that the others are made by Christian?
Please save me from your way of thinking:
Come in to the real world and walk through Europe and see what it is really like to live in a free, democracy where you can virtually do and say what you please without any decrimination:
My friend the criteria that Turkey thinks it has to fulfill and the criteria the EU wants Turkey to fulfill are 2 different criteria:
And you Khan living in London should know better: Go to Carnaby street this weekend and look around and tell me do you see Turkey like that: |
|
| Back to top |
|
Donald Keogh
Villager

Joined: 23 Sep 2005 Posts: 73 Location: Ireland
|
|
| depurple wrote: |
Go to Carnaby street this weekend and look around and tell me do you see Turkey like that: |
No DP, the Grand Bazaar in Istanbul is much better. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Crash Test Dummy Warnings : 3 Ministerial

Joined: 25 Sep 2005 Posts: 4911 Location: London(ish)
|
|
Interesting posts people.
Begs one question; Who (if anybody) should change?
Should Turkey try to fit in with the EU since they want to join? |
|
| Back to top |
|
Donald Keogh
Villager

Joined: 23 Sep 2005 Posts: 73 Location: Ireland
|
|
| depurple wrote: |
You see Khan the EU criteria is not as simple as you and many other Turkish loving people think it is: In any other part of the EU religion. language and the military is in the background BUT where is it in Turkey me know:
|
DP you are being dazzled by the bright lights of Melbourne.
There is only one other country in the EU with a post colonial history similiar to Cyprus and I come from there.
Since 1968 we have had 3000 sectarian deaths, six counties of the country teeming with military personnel, innumerable bombs and the most pernicious religious infighting and intolerance you could possibly find anywhere - and that INCLUDES Turkey & Cyprus -
CTD asks who should change the EU or Turkey ?
My answer is both - The EU, now without a constitution and new members will have to make radical alterations if it wants to survive into the future and Turkey simply because of it's EU membership negotiations.
To suggest religion, language and the military are peripheral issues throughout Europe would have half the population of Ireland laughing all the way from Dublin to Belfast. |
|
| Back to top |
|
depurple Warnings : 1 Ministerial

Joined: 06 Dec 2005 Posts: 2876 Location: Australia
|
|
So Don you see Turkey ready for the EU with its current thinking and mentally?
Or are you suggesting the EU should turn a blind eye to Turkey like the US and Britain has done and let Turkey join and then MAYBE they will change to the EU way of life slowly?
Also coming from Ireland I thought you would of liked to seen ONE United Ireland BUT apparently not:
And that is what you want to see in Cyprus:
A divided Cyprus so you and a few friends can party in the North at the expense of the poor who lost their land and properties like you have been doing for the last 30 years:
BUT what does the EU want Don?
Why didn't Turkey take all of Nicosia when it had a chance in 1974:
Also why did Turkey advance during the agreed UN ceasefire Don?
Maybe theses are too hard for someone like you to answer BUT I am sure you have something up your sleeve to tell me:
"Give Ireland back to the Irish" |
|
| Back to top |
|
Donald Keogh
Villager

Joined: 23 Sep 2005 Posts: 73 Location: Ireland
|
|
| depurple wrote: |
... what you want to see in Cyprus:
|
DP it is up to the two communities in Cyprus to pave their own future.
The same applies to Ireland. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Dhavlos Warnings : 1 Site Admin

Joined: 13 Aug 2005 Posts: 4697 Location: Birmingham
|
|
The question here asks, not whether turkey will fullfill the criteria, it assumes that it does...what it does ask, is whether the EU is able to absorb such a large country....especially with regards to voting right/QMV, the CAP etc...
so really the question is more....can the EU absorb any further? |
|
| Back to top |
|
Birkibrisli
Deputy

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 1404 Location: Australia
|
|
| Khan wrote: |
| No depurple, where in the EU criteria for Turkey to join does it say anything about "change your attitude and thinking"? This is a huge generalisation that suggests the way Turks act and think is inferior. All Turkey must do is fulfil the criteria laid out for it, once this is done, there is no excuse to reject Turkey from the EU. |
Khan...I think depurple represent the western fears about what modern Turkey and her people stand for? It is difficult enough for us of turkish background to analyse correctly what mainland Turkish attitudes and thinking are,let alone those looking from a distance and with a certain preconception. And particularly with the present AKP government and their "warmly islamic" policies,and conflicting social and cultural policy messages,Western people are puzzled in these times of uncertainty brought about by "the war on Terror" and the "Islamic fundemantalism" anxieties.There are fundamental question marks in western minds like:the treatment of women,of different ethnic minorities,of different sub-cultures (like homosexuals for example),of different religious groups etc.
All this before you consider the historical and political issues like Cyprus,the Armenian issue,the role of the Turkish army,and of course Turkey's ambilical cord to the USA,amongst others.
To fulfil the criteria laid out these issues will need to be satisfactorily dealt with,and NOT just by words and legistlation which will remain on selves.
The west is suspicious that Turkey is not ready to embrace honestly the liberal and humanitarian European values.I think that is what depurple is saying in his own inextricable way...  |
|
| Back to top |
|
|