 |
| Author |
Message |
Kifeas Warnings : 6 Ministerial

Joined: 26 Aug 2005 Posts: 2733 Location: Location: Pafos-Cyprus, since 1974 ethnic cleansing. Originally, Lapithos, northern occupied Cyprus.
|
|
| Viewpoint wrote: |
| Kifeas why don't you just admit you have been found out instead of arguing which subjects would effect Turkish Cypriots negatively, why should we leave things to the chance that Greek Cypriots will not manipulate this system to serve their purpose relegating specific issues into levels 2 and 3. Did you not say level 2 it was not possible? and level 3 was very unlikely? I just proved you wrong and what do you do is just brush this aside and continue as if there is no problem with your flawed structure but the problem is my not wanting to accept Greek Cypriot dominance. |
Viewpoint, I have not been found out in anything!
You asked me the following:
| Viewpoint wrote: |
Kifeas you do not know me as well as you think.
Again please dont cloud the issue, just yes or no will do.
Can Greek Cypriots take all the decisions on their own in 2nd and 3rd levels?? |
And I answered in the following way regarding the 2nd level:
| Kifeas wrote: |
| Viewpoint, the answer to your question is NO for the 2nd level. |
Then you came back and said the following regarding the 2nd level:
| Viewpoint wrote: |
No of Communal Greek Cypriot MPs 9plus3who always side with Greek Cypriots for obvious reasons = 12
………………………………………………………………………….
Law Passed. |
In other words, first you ask me if Greek Cypriots on their one (alone,) can take all the decisions, and then in order to prove me that I lied when I said No, you add the 3 MPs from the other communities on top of the Greek Cypriot MP’s so that you show that there is a possibility.
Regarding the 3rd level decisions, I answered to the same initial question as follows:
| Kifeas wrote: |
| For the 3rd level the answer is YES but only in theory, and only if for some weird reason, as many as 72% of all the Greek Cypriot MP’s in the parliament can unite on the basis of communal identity -irrespective of political /ideological differences and policies, with the sole aim and mission to pass a law which 100% of the Turkish Cypriots will object, again for some weird reason. |
You came back and said the following
| Viewpoint wrote: |
Lets examine and test 3rd Level you need;
-The Third Degree (level) will include all the remaining decision making and legislative work of the Federal Parliament and all such decisions will require simple majority of 43 out of the total 84 MP’s, in a unified (non-separated) composition.
Total Number of Greek Cypriot MPs 60
Law Passed. |
Did I say something different than what you said regarding the theoretical possibility that simple arithmetic can make up? No!
Yet, you insist that you caught me cheating, when in reality it is you who is trying to twist the issue around.
| Viewpoint wrote: |
Should Turkish Cypriots accept that fraternizing politically with Greek Cypriots will ensure that all laws passed by Greek Cypriot majority will take into account the opinions and concerns of Turkish Cypriots. Your whole structure is geared towards trusting Greek Cypriots to do the right thing, if thats the case then lets reverse it that privilege and I will guarantee that we will not block or obstruct anything and that everything will go through as agreed with Greek Cypriots. Now find a structure to encompass this but dont try to conceal it this time.
Go back to the drawing board Kifeas your real intentions are evident to all. |
No Viewpoint, not all laws will be passed by a Greek Cypriot majority, alone, without Turkish Cypriot involvement and approval. Level one (1) laws, which are the most critical and fundamental and they are of the real concern for the Turkish Cypriot community, if the entire community is taken as a unified whole into consideration, and which laws are the most likely ones the Greek Cypriot community -as a whole, would like to see them changed irrespective of the Turkish Cypriot will, cannot be changed without a majority Turkish Cypriot approval.
Similarly level two (2) laws cannot be passed without Turkish Cypriot involvement and approval, because it is impossible to get the 100% of the Greek Cypriot MP’s plus those from the other communities to agree on any one issue that falls under this level, while 100% of the Turkish Cypriot MP’s will be opposed. Level 2 laws will involve issues that have nothing to do with the Greek Cypriot ethnic identity Vs the Turkish Cypriot ethnic identity, like those in level 1, but instead will involve laws that involve different socio-political and ideological preferences. This means, for example, that the left wing party(ies) of both communities –together- will have one type of agenda on these issues and the right wing party(ies) of both communities –together- will have a different type of agenda on these issues. Just think how the European Parliament functions, as an example!
The same argument can be used for the level three (3) laws.
I am still waiting for your example. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Viewpoint Warnings : 2 Mukhtar/is

Joined: 14 Aug 2005 Posts: 971 Location: Lefkosa/Nicosia
|
|
| Kifeas for me as a Turkish Cypriot your structure is riddled with dangers for us and open to manipulation of which issues constitute level 1 2 3, that's why I'm not giving you specific issues as they could be contorted to end up in levels 2 and 3 where Turkish Cypriots could be by passed to pss laws that they would heavily be opposed not only that it may effect Turkish Cypriots negatively but all laws. Seeing that you have not admitted that you overlooked the fact that level 2 & 3 are totally Greek Cypriot dominated (taking into account the 3 which all reside in the south) then I take it that you did this knowingly and for me this just confirms my worst fears of Greek Cypriots and their desire not to share decisions equally but camouflage traps in order to gain an advantage over Turkish Cypriots, would you accept it the other way around where those 2 levels were under the total control of Turkish Cypriots?? |
|
| Back to top |
|
Birkibrisli
Deputy

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 1404 Location: Australia
|
|
My Dear Kifeas, I take my hat to you for trying to get through to Viewpoint and those who think like him/her in the NOrth.But you are wasting your time and I think you probably know that. Nothing short of the veto power on every single issue/legislation will satisfy Viewpoint and Co.As you know they are bent on having their own state for the sake of hanging a Turkish flag from every flagpole and house wall.
Talking about flags,do you know that a Turkish Cypriot in the North who hang the Cyprus flag on his house on our republic day was arrested and spent a night in jail recently? The police confiscated his Cyprus flag and he is now threatening them with going to the European Human Rights court to get his beloved flag back,plus an apology.So it is all right to have a Cyprus passport,go and work in the South,but you cannot hang the Cyprus flag in the North.What hypocrisy!
So save your time and energy.I am coming to the conclusion that those of us who live abroad and wish for a united Cyprus before returning permanently have two options: To stay where we are and hope for a just and lasting solution before we die,or to return and live in the Republic of Cyprus and pretend we have a united country. Maybe that is the answer to everyone's question.Maybe everyone who wants a united Cyprus should move from the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus to the Republic of Cyprus as well,and we can get on with forging our Cypriot identity without the likes of Viewpoint vetoing every proposal for unification.That would leave the North to the settlers and the likes of Viewpoint who in my opinion deserve each other(with my apologies to the settlers if that commend has offended them). |
|
| Back to top |
|
-mikkie2-
Mukhtar/is

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 603
|
|
Birkibrisli,
The fact is, the Turkish Cypriot's for so many years have been brainwashed into mistrusting and hating their compatriots, so it is virtually impossible to break down this barrier where the Turkish Cypriot's would want to have a veto right on everything that goes on in the country. Unfortunately, having a system where a veto can be exercised will simply lead us to the tragedies of the past.
There appears to be no want to from either side to build trust. Opening the borders is not enough. The best way for trust to be built os to agrre to the opening of famagusta port for use by both communities and the return of Varosha. This would be the ideal way to actually have the two communities working together for a common goal. That way trust can be built and that way we can move on to better things.
The insitance of the Turkish Cypriot's to want to control every aspect of life simply shows the unwillingness to actually bridge the divide. Talk of 'unification' by the Turkish Cypriot's rings very hollow to me. The progressive forces of both sides of the divide are being suppressed on the one hand by Turkey and the Turkish Cypriot political leadership in the north, and to be frank, by general appathy in the population in the south. Unless these things change - and it will take bold leaders from each side to make the change - then nothing or much worse things will happen. If Cypriots don't t ake control of their own destiny then others will simply manipulate Cyprus for their own ends. |
|
| Back to top |
|
erolz
Site Admin

Joined: 11 Aug 2005 Posts: 4195 Location: Kyrenia / Girne
|
|
| -mikkie2- wrote: |
Birkibrisli,
The fact is, the Turkish Cypriot's for so many years have been brainwashed into mistrusting and hating their compatriots, so it is virtually impossible to break down this barrier where the Turkish Cypriot's would want to have a veto right on everything that goes on in the country. Unfortunately, having a system where a veto can be exercised will simply lead us to the tragedies of the past. |
With respect Mikkie the reason the Turkish Cypriot community does not trust the Greek Cypriot community is less to do with 'brainwashing' and more to do with their historic experiences of living with the numerically larger Greek Cypriot community in the Republic of Cyprus and with effective vetos powers and the continued offical denial on the part of the Greek Cypriot leadership and to a degree wider community about the rerality of this period. It is very hard to trust someone who was invovled in and aware of the killing of your compatriots in the past who today denies that such events ever even occured at all. Brainwashing is not necessary to foster distrust when this is the case. It is not imo the veto powers that led to tradgedy but the behaviour og the two communites and their leaderships. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Viewpoint Warnings : 2 Mukhtar/is

Joined: 14 Aug 2005 Posts: 971 Location: Lefkosa/Nicosia
|
|
On the one hand you want to trust Greek Cypriots in order to build a better future but our mutual history holds you back, its always in the back of your mind will we be able to trust each other, when will Greek Cypriots try to get the upper hand and push us out of Government and authority.. Our unique situation and being a numerical minority makes us extra extra careful when it comes to issues that will reduce our effectiveness/power in a united Cyprus. Having our hands tied in a time of crisis fuels our need to question everything which under normal circumstances you would not even think of twice.
The image of the Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot has to be readdressed to show positivity towards each other, imo the reverse has occurred over the past 2 years as however much individuals interact on a personal level the political personification of each leadership cancels out and positive advances Yorgo and Mehmet may make on a personal level.
For example for me Papadop is a Ex Eoka Turk hater who will do everything to reduce us to minority level in a Greek state. I would never trust anything he has to say even if he said we will recognize the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus I would ask whats the trick, he must be doing something underhand against Turkish Cypriot interests. He maybe genuine in what hes say but his image and personification precedes him so that no Turkish Cypriot could ever trust him with their cat let alone their future. The same could be said of Denktas for Greek Cypriots. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Viewpoint Warnings : 2 Mukhtar/is

Joined: 14 Aug 2005 Posts: 971 Location: Lefkosa/Nicosia
|
|
| Back to top |
|
Birkibrisli
Deputy

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 1404 Location: Australia
|
|
| erolz wrote: |
| -mikkie2- wrote: |
Birkibrisli,
The fact is, the Turkish Cypriot's for so many years have been brainwashed into mistrusting and hating their compatriots, so it is virtually impossible to break down this barrier where the Turkish Cypriot's would want to have a veto right on everything that goes on in the country. Unfortunately, having a system where a veto can be exercised will simply lead us to the tragedies of the past. |
With respect Mikkie the reason the Turkish Cypriot community does not trust the Greek Cypriot community is less to do with 'brainwashing' and more to do with their historic experiences of living with the numerically larger Greek Cypriot community in the Republic of Cyprus and with effective vetos powers and the continued offical denial on the part of the Greek Cypriot leadership and to a degree wider community about the rerality of this period. It is very hard to trust someone who was invovled in and aware of the killing of your compatriots in the past who today denies that such events ever even occured at all. Brainwashing is not necessary to foster distrust when this is the case. It is not imo the veto powers that led to tradgedy but the behaviour og the two communites and their leaderships. |
Erol,
If you want to know what brainwashing is try to find a poem called KIN (Hatred).This poem was broadcast every morning and every evening by Bayrak Radio,from 1963 to at least 1968.If you send me a copy I will translate it into English for everyone to read on this forum.It will make your hairs stand up.Then we shall talk about "brainwashing" and promoting hatred between communities.That poem will stand for me as a monument to a crime against humanity. |
|
| Back to top |
|
-mikkie2-
Mukhtar/is

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 603
|
|
I think the responses I have received prove my point!
If you can't make the sacrifice to trust us, and likewise us trust you, then there is absolutely no point sitting here discussing anything. If people can't 'think out of the box' and simply rely on the experiences of 30-40 years ago to define our future then there is absolutely no hope of a unified Cyprus. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Xenos 2Fan Warnings : 5 Ministerial

Joined: 16 Aug 2005 Posts: 3499 Location: Dallas,Texas/Mersin, Turkey
|
|
Birkibrisli,
I've been looking for this poem but have not found it ....yet. But I shall. With all due respect and to put this title into perspective the definition of "Kin" is not hatred. It is much closer to "nourishing or perpetuating a grudge or ill feelings" after someone has done something to you. All/any Turkish linguists may correct me if I am wrong. |
|
| Back to top |
|
brother Warnings : 3 Site Admin

Joined: 15 Aug 2005 Posts: 8920 Location: London/Cyprus
|
|
| 2Fan wrote: |
Birkibrisli,
I've been looking for this poem but have not found it ....yet. But I shall. With all due respect and to put this title into perspective the definition of "Kin" is not hatred. It is much closer to "nourishing or perpetuating a grudge or ill feelings" after someone has done something to you. All/any Turkish linguists may correct me if I am wrong. |
Kin means grudge/ill feeling and not anything else. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Birkibrisli
Deputy

Joined: 29 Aug 2005 Posts: 1404 Location: Australia
|
|
2Fan/brother,merhabalar
Lets not get hang up on the dictionary definitions of "Kin".
Wait till you read the poem,then we will talk.
Surely someone living in Cyprus must have a copy,or know where to find it.Viewpoint?Are you there?Viewpoint?Hello? |
|
| Back to top |
|
Kifeas Warnings : 6 Ministerial

Joined: 26 Aug 2005 Posts: 2733 Location: Location: Pafos-Cyprus, since 1974 ethnic cleansing. Originally, Lapithos, northern occupied Cyprus.
|
|
I think I know this poem that Birkibrisli is talking about but what I read in a book is that it was being broadcasted to the Turkish troops through the speakers of the landing ships all along their journey from Turkey to Cyprus to take part in the 1974 invasion. It was confessed /explained in a book written by and ex-Turkish army officer who took part in the 1974 operations and gave his testimony while he was living in France.
I believe it goes like this.
"As long as this raunchy (dirty) greek exists on this planet
For Allah's sake, I cannot get over from this rancour.
...........
Not even one thousand heads from the Greeks
cannot wash out this rancour.
............................."
and repeats several times the 2nd and 4th lines.
Last edited by Kifeas on Fri Oct 07, 2005 9:16 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
Xenos 2Fan Warnings : 5 Ministerial

Joined: 16 Aug 2005 Posts: 3499 Location: Dallas,Texas/Mersin, Turkey
|
|
| Birkibrisli wrote: |
2Fan/brother,merhabalar
Lets not get hang up on the dictionary definitions of "Kin".
Wait till you read the poem,then we will talk.
Surely someone living in Cyprus must have a copy,or know where to find it.Viewpoint?Are you there?Viewpoint?Hello? |
Birkibrisli, Selamlar degerli arkadsim.
I wasn't simply relying on the dictionary definition. I was pointing out the everyday use of the term.
For example: Bu adam gercekten cok "kinli".
Translation: This guy is really grudgeful/ holds a grudge.
Hatret=Nefret
I have never used the term nor have I heard the term being used to describe someone that is hateful. I'm not trying to beat a dead horse here just giving my humble opinion.
I still havn't been able to find this poem. If anyone knows where to get it please let me know. Birkibrisli has peaked my attention. I can't really comment on something i have not seen or heard but it sounds to me that it is a poem about not forgetting what happened in Cyprus imo. But I shall shut up and wait to read the poem before plastering conjecture.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
Xenos 2Fan Warnings : 5 Ministerial

Joined: 16 Aug 2005 Posts: 3499 Location: Dallas,Texas/Mersin, Turkey
|
|
| Kifeas wrote: |
I think I know this poem that Birkibrisli is talking about but what I read in a book is that it was being broadcasted to the Turkish troops through the speakers of the landing ships all along their journey from Turkey to Cyprus to take part in the 1974 invasion. It was confessed /explained in a book written by and ex-Turkish army officer who took part in the 1974 operations and gave his testimony while he was living in France.
I believe it goes like this.
"As long as this raunchy (dirty) greek exists on this planet
For Allah's sake, I cannot get over from this rancour.
...........
Not even one thousand heads from the Greeks
cannot wash out this rancour.
............................."
and repeats several times the 2nd and 4th lines. |
Wow! That's pretty intense. I'll wait to comment until I see the entire poem. |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
All times are GMT + 3 Hours Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3 Next
|
| Page 2 of 3 |
|  |
Link Partners

3205 Attacks blocked
Talkcyprus.org - the Cyprus bicommunal discussion and chat forum is Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|